
Silence and small anomalies reveal the true culprit
John Straker dies on the moor while trying to secretly lame the favorite racehorse Silver Blaze to win a bet. Sherlock Holmes deduces that the killer was the horse itself, defending itself in the dark. The watchdog stayed quiet during the midnight theft because the intruder was its own master. Powdered opium hidden inside a dish of curried mutton kept the stable lad asleep throughout the crime.
I. Silver Blaze

